Case of the Poison Powder Chapter 11
Margaret Mitchell Mysteries - The cozy cousin of Carson Crime Files
The Case of the Poison Powder
(Miss Chapter 10? Find it Here) Or start with the first chapter!
Chapter 11
Back at her own desk, Margaret cringed at the memory of her performance in Katherine’s office. She’d gone to share the police’s updates with the team, and to thank Jake—and Katherine—for their help. Spotty dozed on his cushion beside the file cabinet, making little snuffling sounds in his sleep.
Waggling my fingers? Really? Margaret dropped her head onto her desk with an audible thunk.
Spotty lifted his head from his cushion, giving her the terrier equivalent of “You okay there?“
She’d gone to Katherine’s office to share the police updates professionally. Instead, she’d performed like a dinner theater actress overplaying Scarlett O’Hara.
The coy head dip. The giggle that sounded like she’d swallowed a chipmunk. And the finger waggle. She’d actually waggled her fingers at Jake Mercer like some deranged beauty pageant contestant.
Margaret lifted her head and found Spotty now sitting at attention, his little head tilted in judgment.
“Don’t you dare,” she told him. “I saw you try to fight your own reflection last week. You have no moral high ground here.”
Spotty sneezed his most eloquent opinion.
The worst part wasn’t even the performance itself. It was that she’d genuinely wanted to thank Jake for finding the witness, and instead she’d turned it into a humiliating spectacle.
Jake had been perfectly pleasant, as always, but she’d seen Katherine and Lee exchange that look. They knew.
Or at least suspected.
And worse, her behavior was so transparent that it undermined the very real professional respect she had for Jake’s work. He deserved better than her immature theatrics.
Margaret dropped her head into her hands. She genuinely liked Jake—admired his integrity, his loyalty to Katherine. But whatever feelings she had, she needed to handle them with more dignity. Next time, she’d walk in, deliver her information professionally, and leave without the performance.
If Jake was ever going to see her as more than Katherine’s silly friend, she’d have to start acting like the competent woman she actually was.
A knock at her door made her look up.
“Come in!”
The door opened, and Margaret’s embarrassment turned to dread. Heath Griffith stood in her doorway. His expression was grimly neutral.
“Ms. Mitchell.” His voice was cool, professional. “Do you have a moment?”
Margaret’s stomach dropped. ASAs didn’t make house calls unless the news was bad. “Of course. Please, sit down.”
Heath settled into the client chair. “I wanted to speak with you before filing the amended charges.”
“Amended charges?” Margaret’s voice came out sharper than intended. “Heath, the pesticides were recovered. My client has an alibi. Those terrorists had no connection to Sade whatsoever. What possible justification—”
“We have new evidence.” Heath pulled a folder from his briefcase. “And I’m afraid the situation has become considerably more complicated for your client.”
Margaret felt cold. “What evidence?”
“Nick Liu has an airtight alibi for the night of January 8th.” Heath set the folder on Margaret’s desk. “He was at a conference in Philadelphia. Hotel records, restaurant receipts, witness statements from multiple colleagues. He checked in at 4:00 PM, attended a dinner meeting from 6:00 to 9:30, and didn’t check out until the following morning.”
Margaret’s mind raced. “That doesn’t mean—”
“It means he couldn’t have stolen the pesticides himself. And before you suggest he had an accomplice at AgroSynthetics...” Heath opened the folder, revealing technical documents Margaret couldn’t immediately parse. “The facility’s IT security firm conducted an independent audit of the badge system. Their conclusion is unequivocal: Sade Jalloh’s badge was not cloned.”
“That’s impossible.” Margaret grabbed the documents, scanning them desperately. Technical jargon swam before her eyes. Encryption protocols, RFID signatures, and authentication logs. “Badges can be cloned—”
“These badges can’t. Not without leaving a digital fingerprint that would show up in the system logs.” Heath’s voice was patient but firm. “AgroSynthetics uses military-grade encryption specifically to prevent cloning. The IT firm confirmed that only one badge with Ms. Jalloh’s unique identifier accessed the facility that night. Not a copy. The original.”
Margaret set down the papers, her hands trembling slightly. “My client insists her badge was never out of her possession.”
“I know. I’ve read her statements.” Heath leaned forward slightly. “Margaret, I understand you believe in your client. But the evidence is overwhelming. Her actual, original badge was used to access that storage room. The digital logs don’t lie. And now those stolen pesticides have been recovered in the possession of eco-terrorists planning a mass casualty event.”
The words hung in the air like a death sentence.
Margaret forced herself to breathe. “Sade had nothing to do with those terrorists. You said yourself there’s no connection.”
“No connection we’ve found yet,” Heath corrected. “But the federal government takes a different view. The U.S. Attorney’s office is preparing to take over this case. And when they do, your client won’t be facing simple grand theft anymore.”
“What are you talking about?”
Heath’s expression was almost sympathetic. “Once those pesticides ended up in the hands of terrorists planning to use them as chemical weapons, this became a federal matter. The AUSA is preparing charges for terrorism-related offenses, chemical weapon violations under the Biological Weapons Anti-Terrorism Act, cyber crimes for the security breach—” He ticked them off on his fingers like items on a grocery list. “Ms. Jalloh is looking at twenty-five years minimum. Possibly life, depending on whether the government can prove she knew the ultimate intended use.”
Margaret felt like she’d been punched in the stomach. “This is insane. Sade didn’t sell those pesticides to terrorists. She didn’t steal them at all!”
“Then how did her badge access that storage room?” Heath’s voice remained infuriatingly calm. “I came here as a courtesy, attorney to attorney, to give you advance notice. The amended charges will be filed tomorrow morning. After that, it’s out of my hands. The feds will take over, and they’re not known for their flexibility on terrorism cases.”
Margaret followed Health to the door, her mind spinning through possibilities, grasping at straws. “What about the IT firm? Could they have been wrong about the cloning?”
“They’re the best in the region. And they have no reason to lie.” Heath paused at the doorway, turning back. “Margaret, you’re a good attorney. But sometimes the best thing we can do for our clients is help them face reality.” His voice gentled. “The AUSA is going to bury her under federal charges. It will take years for investigators to trace back the full chain of how those pesticides reached the terrorists. Your client could be in her fifties before she sees her children again. Unless...”
“Unless she takes a plea.” Margaret’s voice was hollow.
“If she cooperates now—tells us everything about how she stole the pesticides, who she sold them to, any contacts she had with the terrorist cell—the AUSA might be willing to work with her. Reduced charges. Maybe fifteen years instead of life. She’d still see her children grow up. Eventually.”
Margaret felt sick. “You want her to confess to something she didn’t do.”
“I want her to face reality before it destroys what’s left of her life.” Heath’s expression was impossible to read. “Think about it. Talk to your client. Make sure she understands what she’s facing.”
Heath walked out, leaving Margaret standing in her doorway staring at empty space.
Spotty whined from his cushion, sensing her distress. Margaret closed the door slowly and leaned against it, her mind reeling.
Nick Liu had an alibi. The badge couldn’t be cloned. Sade insisted it was never out of her possession. And now federal terrorism charges that would destroy whatever remained of Sade’s life.
Margaret walked back to her desk on unsteady legs and sank into her chair. The construction worker’s statement lay before her. Still valuable, still proving Sade was in Wilmington that night. But suddenly it felt like a Band-Aid on a gunshot wound.
She picked up her phone and called Katherine. Her hand was shaking.
“Kat.” Her voice cracked. “I need you. Now. Everything just fell apart.”
Stay tuned for Chapter 12, next week!
Can’t wait? Paid Subscribers receive full access to “The Case of the Poison Powder” right now. If you’d like to get full novella now, you can upgrade your subscription here.
Margaret Mitchell, her white terrier Spotty, and her gang at the local nursing home tackle Baltimore mysteries with pluck, perception, and palaver.
In anticipation of the full release of this novella, I’m releasing one chapter a week to all free subscribers.